In my U.S. Open wrap-up I noted that we’re “seeing the legacy of the Williams sisters in Stephens, Duval and the promising Taylor Townsend.” Further evidence of this is the aspiring careers of Tornado and Hurricane Black. It’s no accident that we’re witnessing a proliferation of young black tennis players in the women’s ranks - the seeds sown by the Williams family are coming to bear.
Yesterday, espnW published an article profiling the Black family and the rise of daughters Tornado and Hurricane. After having supported the eldest sibling’s (Nicole) aborted tennis career, parents Gayal and Sly fashioned a similar path for their youngest daughters. It’s virtually impossible to believe that the Blacks went about this without Venus and Serena as the blueprint, yet the family seems to distance themselves from the legendary siblings at every turn:
"We’re always going to be compared, but we’re the Black sisters not the Williams sisters," Gayal said. "We’re going our own way. We played the junior ITF circuit, the Williamses didn’t. It’s nice [for Tornado] to be compared to Serena, who’s the greatest of all time, but they want a name for themselves and I think they’ll live up to their own names and win their own Grand Slam titles in years to come."
Tornado may want to have a career for herself because her parents have probably programmed her to say so. Make no mistake, this has nothing to do with what the tennis sisters want for themselves and everything to do with the careful orchestration of their parents.
"Alicia got her name ‘Tornado’ when she was 3 and playing out of her mind," she said. "We couldn’t believe how amazing she was and we knew then we had a champion. When the next one was born, we knew she could do it, too, and so her [legal] name is Tyra Hurricane."
What does it look like for a 3-year old to be playing out of her mind? Surely Tornado exhibited exceptional skills at a young age, but this kind of hyperbole speaks more to the overzealousness of the parents than it does to any prodigious skill shown by the toddler. It also doesn’t help when Gayal refers to Hurricane as “when the next one was born” - the next what?
This is not a case of a parent recognizing aptitude as a child develops and then nurturing that interest. In this instance, there is a seedy overtone that is quite typical of the tennis parent/prodigy relationship - certainly not the first time we’ve seen a family apply such rigid control to a child’s career. The Blacks find themselves trying to do it in a different age for tennis prodigies - gone are the days when adolescent players ruled the tennis world. They rightly point out that they have chosen a different route than the Williams family by playing the junior circuit etc., but they are handcuffed into doing so by a sport that is wholly different today than it was 15 years ago when Martina Hingis toyed with the WTA as a 16-year old. Venus and Serena could overpower a large majority of the WTA tour at that age, but the power game of today requires a lot more physical development and nurturing - both of which require a lot more money.
This is where the unique names of the young women factor into the equation:
"It’s great for everybody, for publicity. Greg Norman was the Great White Shark. Sir Richard Branson said you have to have a brand to use. We don’t want them to be the next Williams sisters or those African-American sisters. They’re Tornado and Hurricane so people can identify them as something other than the next Venus and Serena. And what better marquee above the US Open than ‘Tornado and Hurricane Black?’"
It is the intricate branding of the girls - even from before they were born - that positions them as commodities. It makes for a good story when a parent can predict greatness for a child from an early age and have it actually happen. Many thought Richard Williams was a loon for Venus and Serena’s unorthodox tennis upbringing, but he is now celebrated as a visionary. How often does this story have a happy ending as opposed to disintegrating into a cautionary tale? The Blacks’ narrative of how they planned for this fairytale success borrows from what we’ve already seen with Venus and Serena, but what are the chances that lightning can strike twice and so soon?
While the ESPN piece paints a favourable picture of Sly and Gayal, there is evidence to suggest their parenting is a bit more erratic than was neatly bundled in that story. Responding to a WSJ pieceaddressing Taylor Townsend’s tiff with the USTA last year, Gayal took to the comments section to separate her daughter from Townsend and vociferously side with Patrick McEnroe and the USTA:
As the mother of Tornado Black, Hurricane Black and former player Nicole Pitts (now in medical school). Patrick, Jose and Olga are all doing a great job running the player development program.
Tornado is in the same training program as Taylor and has to abide by the same rules. Tornado also received the same letter warning her about her fitness as did all full time students at usta. Tornado is also black and has a full body of muscle. But Tornado watches her diet, runs on the beach and does extra fitness to meet the guidelines of fitness by the USTA. Why should the rest of the players have to abide by the rules and NOT TAYLOR TOWNSEND!!!
Rather than show some solidarity with Townsend, Gayal takes the opportunity to praise Tornado’s dedication and simultaneously throw Taylor under the bus by questioning her work ethic. Not only was this terribly opportunistic and in poor taste, but also unsettlingly aggressive toward a young girl who presumably shares the same aspirations as her own daughters. It also dehumanized Townsend who, as an adolescent, was presumably experiencing all the awful growing pains that everyone goes through at that time in life - particularly young women. This was expressed quite vocally in the article by Martina Navratilova and Lindsay Davenport, who both decried the gross insensitivity on the part of the USTA.
Just as alarming was Gayal’s effusive praise of the USTA and McEnroe:
Hats off to the USTA PLAYER DEVELOPEMENT for doing a great job with all the up and coming juniors. Because of your great rules and training is why everyone is begging to come to Boca Raton and train now with the best of the best in UNITED STATES!!! If you don’t like the rules?? LEAVE OR DON’T COME!!!!!
Perhaps this was the Blacks’ way of jockeying for more funding from the USTA should Townsend no longer be a part of the program? Whatever the motivation, it was an embarrassing display - although it did make for some juicy reading. I encourage everyone to read through all the comments and see the responses to Gayal’s posts.
*This article is written under the assumption that those comments were in fact from Gayal Black and not from a master puppeteer in search of the next great tennis drama.
As for Tornado Black, recent runner-up at the U.S. Open Juniors (an event not contested by Taylor Townsend who retired from junior competition), she rightly views Serena as the gold standard. Still, she clings to the family mantra that separates her and Hurricane from the Williams sisters at all costs:
I want to be myself and not Serena or Sloane. I want to focus on me right now.
Perhaps there is merit to the argument that the Blacks need to separate themselves from the Williams clan in order to secure sponsorship etc., but the comparison is something they will have to accept if the girls are to become as great as their parents expect them to. The only way they will be known in their own right is if they eclipse the record-breaking achievements of their trailblazers - not likely to say the least. In the meantime, they better get more comfortable with the idea of playing in their lengthy shadows. That they are an embodiment of the Williams sisters’ legacy is something to be proud of. Perhaps the most striking takeaway from their story (thus far) is a better understanding of just how good a job Richard and Oracene Williams did with raising Venus and Serena.
Authors note: special thanks to @ElliottJMR and Courtney Nguyen (@FortyDeuceTwits) who brought both articles to my attention via their tweets!